Sat Aug 09 2003
Arbroath 1 (Dow) v Berwick 0

Sat Aug 16 2003
Dumbarton 1 v Arbroath 1 (Cargill)

Sat Aug 23 2003
Arbroath 0 v Forfar Athletic 0

Sat Aug 30 2003
Arbroath 2 (Cusick pen, McGlashan) v Hamilton 2

Sat Sep 13 2003
Alloa 2 v Arbroath 2 (Graham, Henslee)

Sat Sep 20 2003
Airdrie United 2 v Arbroath 1 (Cargill)

Sat Sep 27 2003
Arbroath 0 v Morton 4

Sat Oct 04 2003
Stenhousemuir 1 v Arbroath 0

Sat Oct 18 2003
Arbroath 0 v East Fife 1

Sat Oct 25 2003
Arbroath 2 (Cargill, McGlashan) v Dumbarton 1

Sat Nov 01 2003
Berwick 3 v Arbroath 0

Sat Nov 08 2003
Arbroath 3 (Dow, Cargill, McGlashan) v Alloa

Sat Nov 15 2003
Hamilton 2 v Arbroath 0

Sat Nov 29 2003
Arbroath 1 (Diack) v Airdrie United 1

Sat Dec 06 2003
Morton 6 v Arbroath 4 (Cargill 2, McGlashan, Durno)

Sat Dec 13 2003
Arbroath 2 (McGlashan, Durno) v Stenhousemuir 1

Sat Dec 27 2003
East Fife 0 v Arbroath 1

Sat Jan 03 2004
Forfar Athletic v Arbroath (postponed)

Sat Jan 17 2004
Arbroath 1 (Cusick) v Berwick 2

Sat Jan 24 2004
Airdrie United 0 v Arbroath 1 (McMullen)

Sat Jan 31 2004
Arbroath 2 (McLean, Cusick[pen]) v Morton 2

Sat Feb 07 2004
Alloa 4 v Arbroath 0

Sat Feb 14 2004
Arbroath 0 v Hamilton 2

Sat Feb 21 2004
Arbroath 0 v East Fife 0

Sat Feb 28 2004
Stenhousemuir v Arbroath (postponed)

Sat Mar 06 2004
Dumbarton 1 v Arbroath 0

Sat Mar 13 2004
Arbroath 0 v Forfar Athletic 2

Tue Mar 16 2004
Forfar Athletic 2 v Arbroath 2 (McGlashan, Diack)

Sat Mar 20 2004
Arbroath 2 (McGlashan, Diack) v Alloa 1 

Sat Mar 27 2004
Hamilton 2 v Arbroath 2 (McGlashan, Diack)

Tue Mar 30 2004
Stenhousemuir 0 v Arbroath 3 (Cusick, Cargill, McLean)

Sat Apr 03 2004
Morton 1 v Arbroath 0

Sat Apr 10 2004
Arbroath 0 v Airdrie United 4

Sat Apr 17 2004
East Fife 1 v Arbroath 2(McLean x 2)

Sat Apr 24 2004
Arbroath 1 (McLean) v Stenhousemuir 1

Sat May 01 2004
Forfar Athletic 1 v Arbroath 2 (McGlashan, Diack[pen])

Sat May 08 2004
Arbroath 0 v Dumbarton 3

Sat May 15 2004
Berwick v Arbroath